The High Court has ordered the Lesotho Highlands Development Authority (LHDA) to release records detailing the land, property and compensation of communities affected by Phase I of the Lesotho Highlands Water Project (LHWP).
The order, made by agreement between the parties this week, requires the LHDA to hand over six sets of records to Seinoli Legal Centre within 14 days, by December 1, 2026.
The case was brought by Seinoli Legal Centre, with support from the Southern Africa Litigation Centre (SALC), following a request for the information first made on March 28, 2023.
According to a joint statement issued by the two organisations on Tuesday following the judgement, the LHDA refused the request in June 2023, arguing that information about affected families had become its “intellectual property.”
It also relied on other reasons throughout the litigation to justify withholding the records.
However, it agreed before the court to release the information.
The six sets of records include completed census and socio-economic survey data on everyone affected by the project; land and asset inventories; disclosure forms showing how each household’s property was valued; compensation values set for different types of assets; compensation offers, signed agreements and grievance records; as well as an overview of cash and in-kind compensation paid.
The records are expected to enable affected families to compare what was recorded about their homes, land and livelihoods before the project, with the compensation they subsequently received.
Until now, the families have had no way of testing the LHDA’s account of compensation against documentary evidence, according to Seinoli and SALC.
To protect the privacy of affected people, names and other identifying details will be removed from valuation forms, compensation offers, agreements and grievance records. Maps and photographs not in the LHDA’s possession are excluded from the order.
The dispute centres on a commitment made when Lesotho and South Africa signed the treaty establishing the LHWP in 1986, that people affected by the project would be left no worse off than before.
Seinoli and SALC say the only way to establish whether this promise has been honoured is to compare the baseline information recorded before the project with what happened afterwards, including who lived where, what they owned, how their property was valued and what compensation they received.
Programmes Manager at Seinoli Legal Centre, Advocate Lepeli Moeketsi said the order would finally allow affected families to seek answers using evidence rather than assurances.
“For more than three years, families who gave up their homes, fields and grazing land for this project have asked a simple question: were we paid what we were promised? Today’s order means that question will finally be answered with evidence rather than assurances,” Moeketsi noted.
He added that Seinoli would examine the records with the affected communities so they could establish whether the promise made in 1986 had been kept.
International Justice Cluster Lead at SALC, Dr Atilla Kisla, said it should not have taken a court case and more than three years for the LHDA to agree to release the information.
“In 2023, the LHDA told these communities that the record of their own losses was its intellectual property. Today, it agreed to hand that record over. That is the right outcome, but it should not have taken a court case and more than three years to get here,” Kisla said.
He pointed out that the LHDA must now deliver the records in full and on time, adding that the figures would establish whether the commitment to leave affected communities no worse off had been fulfilled.
The organisations also argued that information about people’s homes, land and livelihoods, collected by a public institution for compensation purposes, cannot be withheld from them as though it were private property.
The outcome has implications beyond Phase I, as Phase II of the project, centred on the Polihali Dam, is under way and is expected to begin delivering water to Gauteng in 2028 or 2029.
Seinoli and SALC said the order sends an important message to communities and families displaced to make way for dams that they can request baseline information to establish whether promises made to them have been honoured.
The two organisations will review the records with affected communities once the LHDA has handed them over.






